Hello dear
Welcome To The NY Slice
At The NY Slice, we bring a taste of New York right to Greenwood, Indiana. Our story is rooted in the passion for authentic New York-style pizza, featuring a perfectly thin and crispy crust that’s meant to be folded and enjoyed. Each slice can be customized with a variety of fresh toppings, making every visit a unique experience. Customers rave about our flavorful cheese and delicious garlic knots, celebrating family occasions and everyday cravings alike. Run by dedicated staff who embody warmth and hospitality, The NY Slice is not just a pizzeria; it's a community haven for pizza lovers, creating unforgettable moments with each bite.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Breadstix
US$4.9920" Pizza
US$19.9920" Da Big Spicy
US$26.99
20" Da Big Greek
US$26.9920" Buffalo Chicken
US$26.9920" Big Meat Yorker
US$26.99
20" Big Islander
US$26.9920" Bet Da Ranch
US$26.9920" Bada BBQ
US$26.99 About
The NY Slice
Welcome to The NY Slice, a vibrant culinary haven located at 1201 Greenwood Park E Dr, Greenwood, IN. This charming pizzeria is your gateway to authentic New York-style pizza without the need for a cross-country trip. With a phone call to +1 317-887-1009, you can dive into a nostalgic wave of flavors that will transport you straight to the bustling streets of New York City.
If you’re a pizza aficionado, you’ll appreciate the highlight of the menu: Da Big Slice. Each slice features a perfectly thin and crispy crust that can be folded like a true New Yawker would, making each bite an experience worth savoring. Priced at a wallet-friendly US$3.89, you can customize your slice with an array of fresh toppings, creating a personalized pizza experience.
- 20" Pizza: For those with a larger appetite, you’ll find nostalgic 20-inch options that bring back fond memories of Brooklyn. Starting at US$19.99, it promises incredible flavor that will remind you of the best bites from the city that never sleeps.
- Bada BBQ: Grilled chicken drizzled with BBQ sauce, topped with ricotta and a touch of housemade ranch, priced at US$26.99, is a must-try for those who like a little sweetness in their savory.
- Bet Da Ranch: For the savory lovers, you can enjoy grilled Parmesan chicken and crispy bacon adorned with ranch dressing, also at US$26.99.
Customers rave about The NY Slice's offerings. Monika Cindy celebrated Mother’s Day there, exclaiming how the fresh ingredients and robust flavors made the day extra special. Wubbz Wolf, after ordering through DoorDash, was amazed by the variety and quality, marking it as a top pizza spot. Juliana Rose, who cherishes the East Coast pizza experience, found joy in both the pizza and the warm hospitality, while Swanti K celebrated finding that familiar New York taste right in Indiana.
The ambience is just as delightful as the food. The friendly and passionate staff are committed to making every customer feel welcomed, ensuring that this is not just a meal, but a memorable experience.
So whether you’re craving a quick slice on the go, or you plan to feast with family and friends, The NY Slice is the destination for genuine New York-style pizza bliss. With every bite, you’re not just tasting food; you’re savoring a piece of New York history. Come on over and discover why this pizzeria is causing a delicious ripple in Greenwood!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We celebrated Mother’s Day by ordering 3 boxes of pizza from here, and WOW!!! it did not disappoint! If you’re a fan of New York-style pizza, this place is a must-try. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, the cheese is super flavorful, and the toppings were so fresh. Everyone in the family loved it, and it made our celebration even more special. Highly recommended ”
“ Wow!! We Ordered Da Big Greek, Da Meat Yorker, garlic knots and Da Big Greek salad with the Greek dressing! I honestly can’t tell you which item I liked better because it was all perfect!! My son had become a regular there and told us we needed to check it out and I’m so glad we did! It was a DoorDash order and I think it’s mostly carry out only but I will for sure be adding this to the top of my list of favorite pizza spots!! ”
“ I love the pizza and cannolis and garlic knots from this place! Closest thing to the pizza I get on the east coast. Not to mention, this person running this place is also very friendly and outgoing and welcoming to new customers and reoccurring ones as well :) definitely will come again if I am in town. ”
“ FINALLY! I am from New York and I can’t possibly explain how excited I am to have found this place. Tastes exactly like the pizza I grew up on. Smells exactly like a pizzeria in NY. Thank you so much Dan for having this place in Indiana. We will definitely be back and bring our family. Amazing pizza and it’s a MUST HAVE! ”
“ My husband and I went in just for two slices only. When I tell you we went into the car took a couple of bites of this pizza never left the parking lot. Went back inside and order the biggest pizza they had because that’s how good it was. We had to make sure our kids taste how amazing and authentic this New York pizza was.Definitely coming back. ”
“ I could not wait to write this review. Coming from Louisville, this pizza place is absolutely incredible. But the highlight of our visit was talking to Dan, the owner. He operates this location BY HIMSELF. He was soo friendly and excited to talk about this pizza. I will be sure to come back if in the area again & will also be sure to let everyone know about The NY Slice in Indianapolis. ”
“ Im a Hoosier girl who fell in love with East Coast pizza bc my best friend lives in New York. Ive had several places outside of the east coast that CLAIM to be NY Pizza and I'm always left feeling underwhelmed. After seeing reviews for The NY Slice, I thought what could it hurt? So I went and I'm SO GLAD I did. I got a couple of slices and the garlic knots. Damn...delicious. The 1st bite had me in tears bc it was like I was sitting in NY with my bestie. i even went back later with my son and got 2 pies. I definitely wasn't let down. On top of that...I have a new Uncle Dan (hes the owner and sole employee). He took the time to get to know me and talk about our experiences. Hes very genuine and talented. The pizza is ridiculously cheap considering the wonderful quality. We'll be driving the 1hr 8mins to get this pizza on a regular basis. He gets by through word of mouth and reviews, so definitely try it. You WONT be disappointed!! ”
“ Excellent pizza! The owner is really nice and friendly, and he made me feel very welcome even when I ordered close to closing time. We had da big Greek and it’s one of the best pizzas we’ve had in the area. Will definitely be returning for more! It’s a must try if you’re in Greenwood or southern Indy! ”